Past discussion
Week One, Prologue & Childhood
Welcome to the second week of our Cool Bloggers Book Club (CBBC) on My Brilliant Friend by Elena Ferrante. This week we're focusing on the third quarter of the book, Chapters 17-30 in the Adolescence section.
********************
More photos of books people are reading!
********************
What happened in these chapters?
Elena goes to high school! She does well, but mostly because she's trying to keep up with Lila who is somehow doing the same work while she's working at the shoe shop. Rino is obsessed with getting a fireworks display that's bigger than the Solaras' display, but as the celebration unfolds, violence breaks out. Rino shows the shoes he and Lila designed and constructed to his father and violence breaks out. Marcello Solara begins pursuing Lila and eventually asks her father if he can marry her. Meanwhile, Rino puts the shoes in the shop window to sell them. In the last pages of this section, Lenù gets to go to the sea and has an absolutely marvelous time and then learns that the poet from her neighborhood will be coming to the same place she is staying!
********************
Hat mentions (why hats?)/last week's homework:
When the couple went by Rino made a vulgar comment on what the young woman in green should do, with the bowler hat, and Pasquale stopped, he was laughing so hard, and leaned against the wall with one arm. (page 194)
Both Rino and Pasquale seem quite unpleasant to be around. We know from the prologue that Lila names her son Rino - why would she name him after her hot-headed brother?
Did you find your scavenger hunt word in the book?
********************
Lines of note:
Now it seemed that money, in her mind, had become a cement: it consolidated, reinforced, fixed this and that. Above all, it fixed Rino's head...She no longer spoke of money with any excitement, it was just a means of keeping her brother out of trouble. (page 179)
Again, with Rino being out of control. As someone with a troubled relationship with a sibling, I am not certain why Lila has such a loyalty towards Rino.
The image of power had passed in a flash, four young people in a car - that was the right way to leave the neighborhood and have fun. Ours was the wrong way: on foot, in shabby old clothes, penniless. (page 192)
I didn't purposefully pick out quotes with a theme of money/poverty, but lined up with the above quote, it's a bit of a mini-motif.
Gradually I persuaded her to go home, she couldn't stay hiding there forever. I went with her, counting on the fact that my presence would protect her. But there were shouts, insults, some blows just the same. (page 203)
I appreciate that most of references to violence in this book are not graphic, but this really is indicative of how much abuse these girls go through, isn't it? Along with "Every time Lila and I met I saw a new bruise" on the following page.
********************
Thing I looked up:
Barano: I really just wanted to know how far away the seaside place that Lenù visited was. It's apparently still considered a municipality of Naples, but the island it's on, Ischia, is about 30 kilometers southwest of Naples proper.
********************
Next week's homework assignment:
Let's do a close reading practice! Lectio Divina ("sacred reading" in Latin) is a close reading practice based on a monastic Christian tradition, but we can apply it to non-theist works. It's a four-part process. This may not be precisely how you'd do this if you were at your local Bible study, but here's the guidance I'm offering you, based on information from here.
First, flip through the chapters and wherever your finger lands on the page, you'll engage that word or phrase at four different levels.
1) Narrative: Look at the quote and describe its place in the narrative.
2) Symbolism: What metaphors are hidden in the text? What symbols do you see?
3) Reflection: How does this text speak to you in your life today?
4) Invitation: What action are you going to take?
Example:
I flipped to this sentence on page 165 in this week's readings: He became red in the face, he swelled up around the eyes and cheekbones.
1) Narrative: This is Rino getting angry with Lenù and Lila when the girls told him that the shoes he had made were damp after going over some water. He became angry because he didn't like the criticism and felt like Lila was holding back the project's timeline with her need for perfection.
2) Symbolism: I think the words "red" and "cheekbones" are super interesting here. We just had Valentine's Day last week, so red is often associated with love and passion and in Asian cultures it can symbolize good fortune and joy. But that same passion can be linked with anger and violence, like it is in this passage. Red as a way to describe blood, seeing red, etc. I also think cheekbones has this same dichotomy of meaning. Frequently people with good cheekbones are seen as attractive, right? But there's also the idea that cheekbones are often broken in fistfights. So the link with light and dark appear with both words.
3) Reflection: This definitely made me stop to think about how my body reacts when I'm angry or upset. What physical changes manifest? My heartrate goes up, my body starts shaking as adrenaline surges through my body, and my mouth gets dry. I tend to tear up and cry when I'm sad or angry.
4) Invitation: I'm going to try to react better when I'm angered. I do have a quick temper (I'm also super quick to apologize for being a jerk), but I can and should be better able to control my reactions, both mentally and physically.
********************
Questions to ponder:
1) Now that these kids are old enough to leave the neighborhood once in a while, we see more of Naples outside of their neighborhood. What role does Naples have in this story? How would this be a different book if it had been set in Amsterdam or Los Angeles? What about the timing of it as post-WWII?
2) We're halfway through the book now. For new readers, where do you think this story is going? For people who are doing a reread, have you noticed or learned anything new on this read?
3) The framing of this book is that Adult Lenù is writing about her relationship with Lila. Why doesn't Adult Lenù reflect more about the events in the book? She is mostly just reciting facts and rarely gives hints as to how she felt about it then (or feels about it now) or what impact it had on their friendship. Do you have an explanation for how little the author makes use of the framing device?
4) Lenù gets to go on vacation! What's the first time you remember going someplace to relax without your parents?
********************
Upcoming CBBC schedule:
Week Four
Monday, February 26
Adolescence, Chapters 31-45 (pages 212-270 of the paperback Europa edition, up to location 3575 on a Kindle, timestamp 7:37:34 - 10:06:54 on audiobook)
Week Five
Monday, March 4 (update: this originally said March 1 - it is March 4 for sure, for sure)
Adolescence, Chapters 46-62 (pages 270-331 of the paperback Europa edition, timestamp 10:06:54-end on audiobook)
Week SixMonday, March 11
Wrap up!