Sunday, May 05, 2024

20th Anniversary Countdown: Guest Post #3

In celebration of my 20th Blogiversary, I'm having guest posts in the lead-up to the big day. (No, I don't know what's going to happen on the big day - that seems like something for Future Me to worry about.) 

Today, please welcome Nicole!

Nicole is one of the most cheerful people on the internet. I think it's because of her regular yoga practice, walks with her dog Rex, and her beautiful new home. Nicole recently moved to Kelowna in Canada with her husband and two grown sons. She doesn't cook with onions, has adorable gnomes sprinkled throughout her house, and gives great book recommendations. She blogs at Girl in a Boy House and you really should go over there if you have never visited.  


********************
When Engie asked me to guest post for her 20th blog anniversary, I immediately thought I should do a post about books; after all, while our tastes in reading don’t often overlap, we share a deep love of reading. How to choose what books to write about, I wondered, because there are so many that I love, many more than twenty.

I am an avid rereader; if I like a book, chances are that I have read it more than once. If I haven’t, it’s because it’s new. This still didn’t narrow things down much though: most books I own I have read at least twice. It occurred to me that I should write about my favourite books that I have read over and over: each of these books has been read at least three times, and most of them five or more times. Some of them I have read so much they are literally falling apart, which is the sign to me of a much loved book. [Note from NGS: Favourite! ou!]

Nicole's shelves!

Favourite Book of All Time: The Blind Assassin. This is a quintessential Nicole book: it has a sweeping epic love story, complicated female relationships, interesting female characters, subtle commentary on political and socioeconomic factors, different points of view, and, last but absolutely not least, glorious descriptions of clothes and high society functions.

Favourite Childhood Book: Little Women. I have two copies of this, both from my grandmas. One was my Grandma B’s when she was young, and the other was one of a set of children’s books that my Grandma Fern had. I was the only one of her grandchildren to obsessively take an interest in Little Women, which was the only book about girls in the entire set of twenty or so books. I still love it to this day.

Favourite Childhood Book That Contains Uncomfortable Colonialism and a Disturbing Theme About Victorian England and its Treatment of Poor Children: A Little Princess. This riches to rags to riches book is deeply satisfying and also an incredibly interesting reread as an adult, due to the themes already mentioned.

Favourite Childhood Book That Contains A Very Unsettling Plotline: Rose In Bloom. I adored this book and the very wealthy, but philanthropic, Rose when I was a child, and I loved the descriptions of the balls and parties and fabulous clothing. The weird part? The entire plot concerns which cousin will she marry, to keep the fortune in the family. Um, what? Still, worth the read.

Favourite Childhood Book That Discusses Mental Health Before Mental Health Was Discussed: Emily’s Quest. I always identified with Emily, the dark haired nature loving writer who is deeply misunderstood by her family, other than the strange storyline about the neighbourhood guy decades older than her who wants to marry her when she’s a teenager. Is there a weird romance thread going through all these books? Maybe. Anyway, Emily decides to burn her manuscript (shades of Little Women!) and, regretting it, tearfully heads to the stairs – where she trips over a mending basket, falls, and gets a pair of scissors jammed into her ankle. I still will never set anything on top of a staircase.

Favourite Childhood Book That Showcases My Love For Horses And Also Kitchen Cupboards: These Happy Golden Years. I love the Laura/ Almanzo romance (Laurmanzo?) and also can really appreciate the woman who boards Laura when she is a teacher in a one-room schoolhouse, who goes insane in the isolated shanty during the winter and threatens to kill her husband if he doesn’t take her back East. I feel like if I were in her shoes, I’d feel the same way.

Favourite Book Of My Tween Years That Is Incredibly Disturbing On The Reread: Elvis and Me. I loved this book so much at age twelve, it seemed to me to be the most romantic story ever told. Adult me, however, is horrified. There are just so many disturbing details about Priscilla’s youth, their mostly secret relationship, and also the fact that she went to live with Elvis at age 16, when he was 26. When I was young I thought the parents were the meanest parents that ever lived, and now I think WAIT WHAT.

Favourite Book Of My Teen Years, Even Though Thirty Years Later I Discovered The Author Is A Literal Monster: The Mists of Avalon. A retelling of King Arthur’s court exclusively from the point of view of the women in his life, this book is really incredible; historical fiction is so difficult to do well, and this book nails it.

Favourite Classic Of All Time: Pride and Prejudice. “You must allow me to tell you how ardently I love and admire you.” Every time I read this book, I allow it to become my entire personality, saying things like “I understand you completely” in a shady kind of way.

Favourite Classic That Shows In A Devastating Way The Plight Of Women: Sense and Sensibility. Imagine not being able to live in your home anymore, because you are a daughter instead of a son. I absolutely love this portrait of the Dashwood sisters.


Favourite Classic Whose Main Character I Identify With: Emma. This book is so hilariously funny and witty, and I would one hundred percent not realize Mr Elton’s intentions either. 

Favourite Classic That Devastates Me Every Time: To Kill A Mockingbird. This book also contains one of my favourite lines ever: “I thought Jem and I would get grown, but there wasn’t much else for us to learn, except possibly algebra.” [Note from NGS: Wait until Scout has to figure out when if it's time to replace a major appliance or if it can squeak through for another year.]

Favourite Big Bouncy Showbiz Autobiography: Shelley, Also Known As Shirley. Shelley Winters had an incredible early life, it’s a story and a half. Just do yourself a favour and do not read the follow-up book, which is twice as long but 0.01 percent as interesting.

Favourite Short Story Collection: Lives of Girls and Women. This was my introduction to the literary genius who is Alice Munro, and these interconnected coming of age short stories are so brilliant and evocative of a very particular time and place. 

Favourite Book That Grows With Me: Cat’s Eye. The more I read this book, the more it speaks to me. As I get older, I appreciate it more and more.

Favourite Not Interconnected Short Story Collection: Too Much Happiness. The variety of short stories is wild, and this book also contains a novella about 19th century Russian mathematician Sofia Kovalevskaya – one of the first women to teach complex mathematics at a university (in Sweden, naturally).

Favourite Comfort Read: A Diary of a Provincial Lady. I read this when I need something warm and happy; I think sometimes that EM Delafield and I are kind of the same person, I identify with her so deeply. This is such a witty book.

Favourite Memoir: What Remains. This is an ultimately devastating story about Carole Radziwill and her journey from a working class life to becoming an Emmy-winning journalist, who marries Anthony Radziwill and is best friends with Carolyn Bessette Kennedy. Spoiler alert: everyone around her dies.

Favourite Essay Collection: Calypso. If ever I need to laugh until my stomach is hurting and tears are running down my face, I pick up Calypso.

Favourite Book That Makes Me Obsessed With The Author’s Life: Moral Disorder. I have been obsessed with Margaret Atwood for years, and this book of short stories feels autobiographical to me. It ISN’T an autobiography, but I can’t help but obsessively compare details.

Happy Anniversary, Engie!

Rex with Deenie and Heidi, two books that didn't quite make the cut. 

********************
Isn't Rex the cutest dog you've ever seen? Have you read any of these books? I have do admit to a real soft spot for A Little Princess myself. 

59 comments:

  1. You know, I taught To Kill a Mockingbird for more than thirty years. Each time, I reread it right along with my students (sophomore honors). And each time, I found myself loving it more and being more affected by it in different ways. I usually read at least part of a chapter aloud each day to my students, and the final chapter never failed to make me tear up and almost cry. There were some times that I couldn't even get through it.

    I learned a lot about parenting honestly from Atticus in that book--about telling the truth to my sons in language that was pure and on their level.

    It's my favourite book of all time.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Probably mine too, Nance! And yes, Atticus is a solid role model. (Our Scout was named for Scout.)

      Delete
    2. I find TKAM fascinating because a lot of people adore it, but it left hardly a single blip of an impression on me. Maybe I need to reread it!

      Delete
    3. I ADORED TKAM as a teen. My Grade-9 teacher (Ms. Bryant) did a fantastic job of bringing that book to light. I've only re-read it once as an adult, but it's one of the few books I keep on my bookshelf year after year.
      I'd give it a vote for the next CBBC!

      Delete
    4. I added TKAM to my potentials list for next CBBC. We'll see how many books I put out for the vote - right now I have 4 or 5 great candidates.

      Delete
    5. It's such a great book, and I get a lump in my throat thinking about it.

      Delete
    6. When they're at the prison and the people come to lynch the wrongly-accused prisoner, and after it's over Mr Underwood with his double-barrelled shotgun says "had you covered the whole time, Atticus", I always tear up.

      Delete
  2. Yay Nicole! I just remember so vividly the first time I found her blog and stacked up her boy house vs mine - husband - check. Two boys in their late teens - check. Boy dog - aha that's where we're different because at least there is one other female in my house.

    Of course I've read Little Women and A Little Princess, but it's been too long so I don't remember them. If we're talking Little House, I'm a lifelong fan and big ups to Nicole for recommending the podcast Wilder. Yes I remember the woman who boarded Laura so well.

    What luck that I was in the market for an audiobook for my next road trip and not coming up with any ideas. Problem solved with this post because I just got What Remains.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I sometimes wonder how these classics hold up. I have SUCH FOND memories of A Little Princess, but would a reread let me down? Hard to say.

      Reading a memoir where everybody dies would not be my idea of a fun roadtrip audiobook, Birchie!

      Delete
    2. Wilder was such an excellent podcast - have we talked about Pioneer Girl and Prairie Fires? Both really excellent books on the topic as well.

      Delete
  3. Love reading this list! It seems like disturbing romantic relationships are a major theme in your early reading, Nicole. Or maybe that's just books in general.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ha! I'm imaging a conversation.
      Stranger: Oh, you read a lot. What do you read?
      Nicole: Disturbing romantic relationships.

      Delete
    2. Lol, I love a disturbing romantic relationship!

      Delete
  4. Little Women and To Kill A Mockingbird are also on my list of top favorite books of all time!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I tried to reread Little Women and it seemed far preachier than I remember it when I was a child. Maybe we should do it for our next book club read and see if it is as awesome as I thought it was when I was a child.

      Delete
    2. Oooohh. I'd also vote for Little Women. It has been YEARS since I last read this book (I didn't love it, but it's a solid classic), but mostly doing it for book club would give me the excuse to finally watch the most recent movie version. I'm just not a big movie person but I've been "meaning" to watch it for years.

      Delete
    3. Elisabeth!! You can't vote for two!! Little Women is on the long list for the fall CBBC. We'll see. I just didn't adore it last time I tried to read it.

      Delete
    4. Me too Gigi!!!

      Delete
    5. Just watch me, Engie! I'll vote for TKAM, Little Women, AND Anne of Green Gables...

      Delete
    6. Voter fraud!!

      Delete
  5. I've been missing Nicole, so this was perfect to read in so many ways!

    Thanks for this great list, Nicole--it links with my own favorites in so many ways. I haven't read Delafield, but it's on my TBR because of you.

    Have to say--I loved Eight Cousins and Rose in Bloom because they seemed like they could have been about my mom's generation (cousins do marry in South India). I got that feeling about Leo Tolstoy's work too... Great literature is so transcendent of geopolitical space!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I love that we were able to get this scheduled for during Nicole's blog break so everyone could still get a little bit of Nicole while she's traveling!

      I'm interested hardcore in the idea that cousins regularly marry. How does that work long-term?!

      Delete
    2. That's how it worked all over the world for the longest time, according to studies! And I see it mostly amplified in diasporic communities (Jews, Muslims, Parsis) and in families with extreme wealth or poverty. I think people used to worry about genetic recession in consanguineous marriages, but that has been largely disproven.
      https://www.nytimes.com/2002/04/04/us/few-risks-seen-to-the-children-of-1st-cousins.html https://www.popsci.com/marrying-cousins-genetics/

      Delete
    3. Eight Cousins I loved too!!! I have never before known someone else who was obsessed with Rose in Bloom, of COURSE you would be too, Maya!!! xoxoxo missed you too

      Delete
  6. Rex!!! So glad he made an appearance. So many great books here! I LOVE Jane Austen, and there's a copy of Emma sitting on my night table just waiting to be re-read. Some of these I haven't read- Rose in Bloom sounds good! And I've never read The Blind Assassin- but now I want to. Whenever someone can actually identify a "favorite book of all time" I want to read it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, I was so happy she included a photo of Rex - now I have one on my blog! I recently read The Blind Assassin on Nicole's recommendation and I found it lovely, but honestly wasn't sure what the take home point was, so I was a lot more lukewarm on it than Nicole. But boy can Margaret Atwood write!

      Delete
    2. Oh, I love The Blind Assassin with all my heart! I love almost everything Atwood has written, but this is top for me.

      Delete
  7. I also love The Little Princess. That is one book I have also read over and over! I did like the House on The Prairie books but didn't enjoy the adult years as much when I was younger. I wonder if they will be more interesting now that I am also grown.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I never read the House on the Prairie books. I'm clearly an outlier and maybe I should read one or two!

      Delete
    2. It's DEFINITELY a ride to reread These Happy Golden Years, particularly the ones about the one-room schoolhouse and being boarded by someone who was probably suffering clinical depression.

      Delete
  8. I enjoy Nicole's blog and like her answers to the questions. I haven't thought about The Mists of Avalon in years! I read it as a teen and it made a huge impression on me, too. Rex is a delight, so photogenic, but way cool about it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I read Mists of Avalon in 2018 and then I looked up Marion Zimmer Bradley and wished I hadn't. *sigh* I'm currently reading a Mercedes Lackey series that has tie-ins with a Bradley series and I am missing a lot of background by not reading the Bradley stories, but now I'm skeeved out. The woes of a fantasy lady!

      Delete
    2. Ally, it made a huge impression on me too! I just loved it so much!

      Delete
  9. Hi Nicole! This was so much fun! When I think of books: I always think of NGS and Nicole. :) Love the cameo by Rex.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm so grateful to be in the same sphere of reading as Nicole. We read VERY different things! I love that Rex is not permanently on my blog.

      Delete
    2. Aw, thanks you two!!! And yes, we have different tastes but we are both passionate about reading!

      Delete
  10. I have read several of these books and feel so inspired by Nicole to reread all of Austen's oeuvre! Love this list AND the photos -- what a collection, Nicole. And your piles of deeply loved books make my heart so happy. Also: REX!!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Right? Those bookshelves. *sigh* Such a beautiful place!

      Delete
    2. You know a book is loved if it's literally falling apart!

      Delete
  11. Ah, so many of my childhood favorites! A Little Princess, Rose in Bloom, Emily's Quest, These Happy Golden Years...when I was a kid, I found Almanzo's courtship of Laura so romantic, though now I'm not as certain. And yes, the cupboards that he built for her! I bet that man would have been very handy to have around. Bookshelves, yarn storage...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Honestly, I need to read some of these LIW books. Everyone else has such great memories of them and all I remember is thinking the television show as a real snooze. LOL.

      Delete
    2. I mean, he also put them in terrible debt, so that's not great - but those cupboards!

      Delete
  12. I've never read A Little Princess, but my daughter played Miss Minchin in the play version last year so I'm now very (very) familiar with the plot.
    All time favourite book: The Trolley Car Family which is an obscure kids chapter book from Scholastic that I love and treasure so, so much.
    Favourite series as a kid: Nancy Drew
    Favourite series as a tween: Harry Potter
    Favourite series as an adult: ???
    Favourite "classic": well, it used to be Jane Eyre and then I re-read it last year with adult perspective and loathed it. Like loathed, loathed, loathed it. Sigh. I am now very wary of re-reading old favourites. But one series that has stood the test of time for me is the Anne of Green Gables books, well at least the first three. They are just heartwarming.
    I re-read the Little House series to my kids at the start of the pandemic. They are classic, though some things have not aged well. The original Boxcar Children book is amazing.
    The Grapes of Wrath was a big love of mine but, again, when I re-read it as an older adult it didn't land as well. Plus, it is extremely depressing.
    I didn't really enjoy my re-read of Pride and Prejudice last year, but I do want to re-read Emma because I remember loving it. Though, sigh, have I learned nothing from my re-reading of classics in the past?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Reading our old beloved books is always a risk, isn't it? I was so happy that I loved ATGIB when we read it again, but I know you didn't love it as much as I did.

      My favorite series as an adult is probably the Alphabet mystery series by Sue Grafton. Those books, particularly the early ones, are such a comfort read for me.

      Delete
    2. I love the first three Anne books too - the other ones, maybe not so great!

      Delete
  13. I love A Little Princess, and I enjoy rereading it from time to time. Have you seen the movies? As happens all too often, they get the ending wrong in such a spectacularly horrible way, it's depressing. The gift that Sara gives the Indian Gentleman, true forgiveness and love...incredible. In the movies, she doesn't believe her father is dead, she keeps looking for him, and YAY! finds him. Of course as a kid I would rather find my father alive than befriend the man who was involved in his death, but I really think they got that wrong in the movies. Sigh.

    If you decide to read the Little House books, just understand not only when they took place, but when they were written. There are scenes that are so uncomfortable and would not fly today, but no one thought anything of them at the time. Laura the author did not want to hurt anyone, and when she discovered a phrase in one of her books was hurtful, she had it changed.

    Oh, Mists of Avalon...yes, I loved that book. Will I ever be able to read it again, knowing what I know now? Doubtful. Perhaps I should throw it away. But I loved it so much. Devastating.

    I'm realizing that I don't think I've read The Blind Assassin (or else it didn't land well) and I generally enjoy Atwood, so I am going to have to do something about that. I love Alice Munro, too, and not sure I have read that collection.

    What a great list, thanks Nicole (and Engie!)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. J, YES ON THE MOVIES! Movies always get it wrong!!!

      Delete
  14. Yay, so happy to hear from Nicole and such a great twist on books and 20 things. I've read a few of the books, all the Jane Austen ones that were mentioned. I had a Jane Austen class in college and I loved it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The only Austen I've read is Pride and Prejudice and that was in high school. I don't know if I'm the right reader for Austen! How many of the books did you read in that college class?

      Delete
    2. A whole class in Jane Austen, how wonderful!

      Delete
  15. What a great post. Admittatly I haven't read many of those. Which only shows that growing up in different countries (languages) there are different books available maybe...

    I totally agree on "Favourite Book Of My Teen Years, Even Though Thirty Years Later I Discovered The Author Is A Literal Monster: The Mists of Avalon." I think I read all of her books in a certain phase it it was definitley where I discovered my love for historic fiction. I was shocked when I heard a couple of years ago what was going on in her private life. I always wanted to re-read the books though...

    I have not yet read to Kill a Mockingbird but really want to. Maybe a great CBBC book, Engie?!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I haven't heard of a bunch of these books, either, if that makes you feel better, Tobia. Even with the same language, but different countries, there are cultural differences in what books come across our radars.

      Marion Zimmer Bradley let us all down. Mists of Avalon is a feat of feminist literature, but knowing what was going on in her personal life is disturbing and makes me read it with a different lens that decrease my enjoyment.

      Hmm...I currently have four potential options for our next CBBC book and TKAM is on that list. We'll have to vote on it!

      Delete
    2. Tobia, I was completely shocked and upset by it. I just loved that book so much and was horrified to find out what the author was!

      Delete
  16. To Kill a Mockingbird remains one of my all-time favorites. I haven't read A Little Princess since I was a kid... I may need to do a reread at some point to see if it lives up to my memories.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. These classic children's books are classic for a reason, I guess. They hold up over the years through multiple generations of children and into adulthood. Imagine being the author of one of the books - Harper Lee, Betty Smith, Frances Hodgson Burnett - and how they didn't know how influential their words were going to be!

      Delete
    2. TKAM is just so wonderful, and I get something new out of it every time I read it.

      Delete
  17. ooooooooooh The Little Princess!! So much better than A Secret Garden, and your category for it made me LOL

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hahaha well it's true! You know, I have never gotten past the first chapter of A Secret Garden, never. I just can't do it!

      Delete
    2. Hey, hey, ladies!! The Secret Garden is a WONDERFUL book - Mary is so lonely and terrified at first, but the character development in that book is amazing!! FHB's books are ALL great.

      Delete