A couple of years ago, I wrote an appeal for help in my life and I learned about Dove body scrub from Kim and it has been life changing (also, we bought a water softener), so I'm appealing to the blogoverse for more help. As per usual, this starts with rather lighthearted, easy questions and then I will hit you with a tough one at the end, so just beware.
1) As some of you may know, whenever I exercise at home, I burn a candle. My current candle is almost at the end of its life. FEAR NOT. Costco to the rescue. For some crazy low amount of money, I was able to procure a package of 4 11-ounce candles in the following flavors scents: cherry grove & plum; forest moss & cypress; coast redwood & fog; and blue mist & sea. What should my next candle be?!
2) I'm not reading my physical book, so I'm going to DNF it. I hope to have some time over the weekend to read, so what should I read next? The Vegetarian, The Tainted Cup, or After the Eclipse? I bought a copy of The Vegetarian when I thought it was going to win the CBBC vote and I do want to read it. The person who suggested The Tainted Cup to me said it was Sherlock Holmes but FANTASY. I didn't even know I wanted that until it was described to me. After the Eclipse is a wildcard for me. It's a memoir about a daughter whose mother was murdered and the aftermath of that terrible event. I don't know. Tell me what to read.
3) Do you remember how my mom lived on a tiny house on my sister and brother-in-law's property? And that tiny house was next to a tiny house that my brother-in-law's mother lived in? If not, that's okay. Here's a picture of the tiny houses - the photo is from 2025 and I assume they still mostly look like this.
My sister and her MIL did not get along. I wrote this in 2022 and, as of my mother's death in August of 2025, the two of them were still not speaking. I don't know what has happened in the last year because my mom isn't around to give me the hot goss anymore and my sister doesn't talk to me. Listen, I am not someone who goes around talking about my grief and how much I miss my mother, but MAN DO I MISS HER FILLING ME IN ON THE DRAMAZZZZ.
My brother-in-law's mother died this past week. I found out via Facebook.
I'm going to send a sympathy card.
The question is: do I address the sympathy card just to my BIL or do I also include my sister? My sister and I don't really talk to each other and she basically despised her MIL. BUT. If my sister wrote a sympathy card to my husband and didn't mention me, my feelings would be hurt. I'm trying to do a nice thing with this card, not cause hurt feelings or marital strife. However, my sister might interpret me adding her name as being snarky (which - fair - I am a snarky bitch, but I am not usually passive aggressive re: dead and dying relatives) because I know how much she didn't like this woman.
This is really impossible for you to answer, I guess. The dynamics here are impossible to untangle. My husband and I spent a good hour hashing it out over dinner on Thursday night and the card is just sitting on the table because I'm unable to make a decision.
What would you do?
***************
Non-advice reminder: If you want to send me a photo of your CBBC, please sent it to me before noonish on Sunday so I can include in the week two roundup.
***************
Sound off and tell me what to do!!

Subject matter expert in communication here: put both names on the card; include polite and direct note inside where you make it clear you are sincerely offering sympathy to your sis.
ReplyDeleteEh. I am not really offering HER sympathy, but him. But I put both names on the card and included my husband in the dealio, too. Hopefully it will be taken in goodwill.
DeletePossibly your card and the message can be successfully crafted to commiserate but to avoid offence??
ReplyDeleteRight? But what is that message? It's not easy!
DeleteTainted Cup!
ReplyDeleteThat seems to be the consensus!
DeleteSigh. Family dynamics are so fraught; I empathize.
ReplyDeleteWhen in doubt, take the High Road. Put both names on the card, and if you have one, write a brief memory of yours about the deceased. Even if it's simply "When I visited, she was so kind and welcoming" or "I always took note of the pretty flowers in front of her home" or "I remember hearing her laugh and thinking how genuine it was." Failing all of that, merely writing that loss is always difficult, especially when it's family, and remark at their kindness of having the tiny home(s) on their property for her.
I'm currently reading May We Feed The King, and although I'm only about 50 pages or so in, I am fascinated by this slim little book. I just finished The Dutch House, which I liked pretty well, but Maya made the point that it's almost a retelling of Jane Eyre, and now I can't stop thinking about that.
Honestly, Nance, those are all good suggestions, but I went even more generic with that. Sorry to hear about your loss. We're thinking of you in this difficult time. End. I don't know. None of the rest it felt genuine. (My favorite memory of the deceased is when we were in the backseat of a car my sister was driving and we both - very quietly - made fun of my sister's driving and road rage. I did not think that was appropriate to share, although I hope that somewhere this lady knows that I think about that drive a lot.)
DeleteThe Dutch House. LOL. I wanted that book to be about some of the tertiary characters instead of the boring siblings. I do not understand Ann Patchett books.
1. I'd go for forest moss & cypress. It sounds like a fall-ish scent.
ReplyDelete2. I'd read Tainted Cup. Sherlock Holmes and fantasy - who could resist?
3. That is tough. I'd send the sympathy card to both with a sincere sorry for your loss, but no more. Even if she hated her MIL, excluding her from the card would be hurtful.
All that being said, please do whatever is in your heart on all three!
I think you might be right on all three action items! Maybe next time I should just go straight to you.
DeleteFirst I am really sad that your sister doesn’t speak to you. The fact that she also “despised” her MIL makes me think she’s not a happy person. Sad. I do think you should write both names on the card and a short sincere note of sympathy.
ReplyDeleteShe's really not pleasant to be around. I try to be understanding, but I don't really understand why she is the way she is. I did write it out to both of them.
DeleteI can't help on the books because I now want to read all of them too.
ReplyDeleteInclude your sister in the card. She will almost certainly have complicated feelings about her MIL's death, and that's hard. Add that to the potential hurt feelings, and I don't think there is a downside.
I'm sorry your relationship with your sister is complex.
You know what? You might be right that she has some guilt over how she treated her MIL. I guess I wasn't really putting myself in her shoes enough to see that. It's a good point. I included her and hope she knows it's sincere.
DeleteI really want to know what ‘coast redwood and fog’ smells like, it sounds like heaven to me.
ReplyDeleteI would read whichever book sounds like the most fun (probably the fantasy book).
I know your relationship with your sister is crappy, but I love that she and her husband had these tiny homes built for their mothers. I wonder what they will do with them now? AirBnB? Leave them empty? I agree with everyone else, include your sister in your card and hope for the best. I think about you and your mom every so often…from my experience, it will never be easy to not have her here, but it will be easier at least. Hang in there. SAD to not have the gossip anymore. Oh, BTW, my husband’s SIL died a bit ago, and we found out via Facebook as well, since he and his brother don’t talk. His brother didn’t call to let him know, and my husband didn’t call to give his condolences (or send a card, or anything at all). It’s really sad.
I am so amused by the names of candles. Coast redwood and fog could be great, right?
DeleteListen, my mother paid for and oversaw the construction of those cabins. My brother-in-law did help with maintenance, but my mother paid LOT RENT every month to live there. They did not do this from the kindness of their hearts. Last I heard (in 2025), my sister and her husband were not on the same page about what to do with the cabins and it was a moot point because his mother was still alive. I can't imagine there's a market for an AirBnB where they live. I don't know if I'll ever know.
Your mom paid for the construction of BOTH cabins? Knowing one would go to the MIL? WOW WOW WOW. That is amazing. I kind of want to know what’s going to happen with them next, but as you said, unlikely to happen.
DeleteThe Tainted Cup!! I think it fits your fantasy tastes ( with a very rich universe) but the mystery part is awesome. I did have trouble following at first- the roles and hierarchy not explained well. But it's become apparent as you move along. I did notice in the second book that he put a list of roles/ titles in the front. I enjoyed the second and third books more.
ReplyDeleteSend it to both BIL and sister. She might not be grief stricken, but her husband will probably appreciate that you recognized the whole family is impacted by the death.
Oh, man. It's not a standalone?! I thought it was a standalone. *sigh* Fantasy authors can never just do things in a single tome, can they?
DeleteAdd your sister's name to the card; take the high road and know that you are sending it with the best of intentions. How she receives it is on her, not you. As much as she despised her mother in law, she still had her living on the property and she deserves kudos for that. Family is hard no matter how you slice it.
ReplyDeleteDammit! That's me - but the system won't let me sign in! Gigi
DeleteI have listened to everyone's advice and added her name to it. I feel best about this and if she does get upset, I'll never know.
DeleteFamily dynamics are so hard. I am quasi-estranged from one of my sisters (we text each other on our birthday's and that's about it) and it's horrible and hurts my heart. So... HUGS.
ReplyDeleteI agree that I would put both names on the card, as per the recommendations above.
I sent my sister and brother-in-law cards on their birthdays and did not get one from them on mine, so I don't know if we're even quasi-estranged, but maybe just estranged estranged. It makes me feel like I'm a bad person, to be honest. Oh, well. Families are hard.
DeleteCoast Redwood!
ReplyDeleteI have not read any of the books, but did have The Vegetarian on my list, so...that one.
Both names. Better to err on that side than the other in my opinion.
Good luck!
Either coast redwood or forest moss (lol at these names) will probably win. I'll sniff them and see which seems like the most fall scent.
DeleteCoast Redwood & Fog sounds lovely and perhaps thematic for spooky season?
ReplyDeleteThe Tainted Cup should be the next book.
I agree with others on including your sister. I’m sorry there is so much fraught-ness with the relationships. I appreciate your desire to send condolences and be thoughtful. ❤️
-steph
Yes, I think I'll sniff through them and see which one is the most autumnal. Let nature decide the candle scent!
DeleteI don't know if my sister will read it as thoughtful, but, on the bright side, I won't hear about it if she doesn't because she doesn't talk to me. :)
I don't do scented candles, so I'm probably no help. I like the names of all of them, though.
ReplyDeleteI would have done what you did and put your sister's name on the card too. It's the right thing to do for anyone else and you can't really control her reaction, right?
The names are so funny. I think having a candle naming job would be fun.
DeleteYes, you're right. I can only control what I do and I sincerely do feel bad for them. I can't imagine how different their lives must feel every day now.
I have read and loved another "Sherlock Holmes but fantasy" book, The Angel of the Crows by Katherine Addison, so I approve the concept but probably won't read another in that category myself. Though these days, I'm not into heavily emotional/tragic stories, so probably not that either! I'm no help here.
ReplyDeleteAh, yes, I'd forgotten about that Addison book. I thought it was okay, but don't think I loved it as much as you did. I think I'm going to go for The Tainted Cup next. We'll see how it goes.
DeleteMy votes were The Tainted Cup and address the card to both of them. Sounds like that's the general consensus, so carry on!
ReplyDeleteI'm reading/commenting in reverse order, but that's the way I'm rollling today. If it were me, I'd go with the cherry/plum candle. I love cherries though, so that might not work for you. I'd address the card to both sis and BIL. I did laugh out loud at the story of the shared laugh at your sister's driving. (hey, those of us with difficult sisters should maybe stick together - I have a similar story about being stuck in the backseat while driving home from a funeral with them in MN. them being my two sisters, both gems). If it were me, I'd read the memoir. I like memoirs though, but I feel like you like fantasy more than me. That memoir does seem really sad though.
ReplyDeleteI think I'm going with cherry/plum in spring. It seems like a spring scent!
DeleteI've never thought about burning a candle while exercising----I kind of dig this idea.
ReplyDeleteI hate that you have this fraught relationship with your sister. I honestly forgot that your Mother and the mother-in-law lived next to each other. Damn, that must have been tricky if they didn't all get along. I would bite the bullet and address the card to both. Seems either way she won't be happy, but at least you tried.
I don't know anything about the three books you mentioned, so go with the shortest one?
Oh, the candle is my special treat to make me *want* to exercise more. Does it work? Sometimes. I really recommend it if you have a space to make a candle work wherever you exercise. Because of the dog and cat, we don't burn candles downstairs very often because they are menaces and I don't want either of them to catch their tails on fire, so it has to be when I'm upstairs and the vast majority of my upstairs time is when I'm exercising.
DeleteI have not read any of those books so I am not much help but I've heard rave review of Tainted Cup so maybe start with that? Re: your sister. Ugh ugh ugh. I think I would include her name on the card. Whatever you do, the relationship is probably already damaged beyond repair (which I 100% can understand and relate to) so addressing it will maybe keep at the current level of damage versus further damaging it? Or not. *shrugs shoulders* Family dynamics are HARD.
ReplyDeleteObviously my comment comes WAY too late and you've already solved the dilemma, but yes, common courtesy demands that you put your sister on the card - and let her take it the way she wants. You couldn't really "win" either way, but I think you did the right thing.
ReplyDelete