Tuesday, May 10, 2022

Family Gossip

My dad's side of the family is known for carrying grudges. My father did not speak to his own father for decades. I remember being introduced to my grandfather at a family funeral by a nosy aunt and my father was absolutely furious. He then did not speak to that aunt for years and years. My sister and my father actually didn't speak for about a year when I was in early grad school and I remember my dad calling me to get gossip about her. Ha. Good times. 

So.  Keep all of that in mind as I tell you this story that amuses me greatly.

Major players

My sister: May
My mom: My mom
My sister's husband: Buddy
My sister's mother-in-law, Buddy's mother: Carly

My mom and my sister May live in a different state from me. My sister is married to a guy named Buddy. Buddy's mom is an elderly lady named Carly (as I type this I realize that makes my own mother an elderly woman and I refuse to admit that at all). At a certain point several years ago, my mom and Carly retired at roughly the same time. The moms decided to buy tiny houses and put them on my sister and Buddy's property which is about forty acres of a mostly wooded property in middle America. Their reasons for this particular course of action are a bit mystifying to me, but basically they wanted to have companionship, be near their children (not me, I guess), and save money. 

I spent months trying to convince my mom and May that this was a bad idea and that my mom should rent an apartment in the nearby town and come visit May all the time, but they kept on with the tiny home idea.

My mom fronted the money for all of this with the understanding that Carly would pay her back for the costs of the tiny house and that my mom and Carly would pay May and Buddy lot rent.  So, there are two tiny homes on May and Buddy's property, along with the so-called "Big House." My mom and Carly basically just slept in their tiny homes, but spent most of their time in the Big House, where they did laundry, cooked, bathed, and pretty much lived their lives.

This worked well for a bit. There were occasional moments of tension, but they bumped along. Until Christmas of last year. May and Carly got into a huge fight at Christmastime, with Carly telling May that May doesn't treat Buddy right (which, to be fair, might be a fair point) and May telling Carly that she won't be told what to do in her own house. They have not spoken to each other since then, which is over five months as I write this. (This is where the story from above fits into this. May has definitely taken the stubbornly holding onto grudges trait from my father.)

Meanwhile, poor Buddy is stuck going back and forth between his wife and mother. He's constantly ferrying Carly around because she can't drive and she won't ask my mom or May to take her places. Carly won't eat at the Big House anymore, so Buddy walks her meals to and from the Big House for her. And May and Carly constantly complain to him about the other person. It's a big mess for him and I honestly feel terrible for him. (Except for the fact that he was also in support of the Tiny House Plan from the beginning and a tiny part of me feels like he really brought this onto himself...)

And my mom? My mom tries to invite Carly when she's going to do things like shopping and going out to eat or whatever, but Carly barely speaks to my mom who has tried to be Switzerland throughout this whole thing. I think Carly feels some guilt regarding my mom because guess how much she has paid my mom back for the tiny house? I don't need to tell you that it's zero dollars, do I?  

Meanwhile, I just sit back and watch the whole thing unfold from another time zone and enjoy the juicy texts my mom sends me.

Today's texts from my mom:
I found out today that all of Carly's dirty clothes are in her shower. She won't take them up to the Big House because she doesn't want to run into May.

Evidently she just buys new at the dollar store. Is that crazy or just weird? Hit me over the head if I get like this. 

Question for you:
What's your family drama?  I want the juicy deets!

13 comments:

  1. Wow! I actually know a family that has a similar situation; a son/daughter-in-law built on to the parents/in-laws home (like built an addition on to the home) and then the relationship soured such that the in-laws moved out of their home (into a rental) while the son/daughter-in-law (now with two children) built a home (but, I think, still on the same property)?
    This feels like something from a novel or movie (or reality show). I'm so sorry your Mom is caught up in all of this.
    My family doesn't have anything this intense, but I do have two siblings that do NOT get along with each other. They never have, honestly, and it has only gotten more intense with age. I'm the baby in the family and get along with everyone - I don't think anyone ever saw me as a threat because I'm A LOT younger than my siblings.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Families, eh? Sue's family are/were all friendly except for the middle sister who won't even talk to her kids. And her female kid is just about as bad in here own way.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Waitaminute... if Carly's dirty clothes are in her shower, how is she showering? Is she at least bathing some other way? Because the clothes thing is definitely weird, but if she just isn't taking care of herself, sounds like more might be going on. Ew.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I checked with my mom on this and apparently Cindy removes the clothes before showering, but she IS showering.

      Delete
  4. This is WILD. I keep sitting here reflecting on all the details -- the clothes in the shower! the non-existent payment for the house! Buddy walking food back and forth to his mom! -- and being gobsmacked anew. I am NOT a grudge keeper (although I know a couple of people who are really good at it) so I cannot fathom how people do it!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh: My family drama. I have a cousin who refuses to speak to ME because HER father refers to me as "The Perfect Daughter." We don't see each other very often, but sometimes our other cousins include us on group texts and she just... won't respond to me. Also, when we had a family reunion awhile back, she completely ignored me.

      Delete
    2. Oh, wow! How funny that she holds a grudge against you for something you have absolutely not control over!! What kind of inner life she must have!

      Delete
  5. O.M.G. What a stressful situation! I am so conflict avoidant that reading about this almost gives me the shivers! Eeks. The whole situation sounds so unsustainable, but I'm guessing your mom is kind of stuck there since she's bought 2 tiny houses... When you said she fronted the money my immediate thought was: 'oh no, this is not going to end well.' Ay yi yi.

    We have had our share of drama in our family. There aren't any grudges like what you describe, but we have some big and very different personalities, and then if you add alcohol to the situation it's a disaster in the making... My husband and I are both on the quieter/less emotive side and are both conflict avoidant. Like life is stressful enough without adding disagreements, arguing, etc. So we kind of try to avoid large family gatherings to the extent possible, because the more people, the more chance for conflict.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Wow. WOW. I just read this with my eyes getting bigger and bigger and WOW. I don't even know what to say. Except...wow. I'm imagining what this must be like for everyone involved. I don't believe in carrying grudges so I am also completely amazed by the YEARS of grudges! I can't even! Now, believe me, I have major family drama but I can't write it down because there are eyes everywhere and who knows who will see what, but I will just say that I have never found reality TV appealing because my own family is so crazy.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I agree with Elisabeth- tis has the makings of a reality show. I mean, the whole thing with the tiny houses to start with- who thought that was a good idea??? Especially when you're dealing with people who might be a tiny bit unreasonable and like to hold grudges. I'll be you're glad you're safely in a different state! You'll have to keep us updated now. Maybe there can be monthly installments on the "Tiny House" drama.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I was shaking my head "oh no, no, no" when I started reading this. This is truly wild. Who thought this was a good idea? Who didn't see the problems coming?
    Honestly, I am so glad you're far enough away to not get involved (although I truly understand that you feel bad for Buddy!). Maybe they need an intervention of sorts?

    I think every family has some drama. While I am super-close with my side of the family, there is some drama with my mom's younger sister (who is 15 years younger with a bit of a troubled past, who has always relied on my mom as her "substitute mom" (my grandma died young) and asks unreasonable things of her all the time). On my husband's side, there's a lot of dysfunction too and let's just say that I am really glad we live 300 miles away and don't have to be part of the drama between my in-laws and them and my husband's brother.)

    ReplyDelete
  9. Oh wowwww, this is a crazy story! Family dynamics can be so tricky, especially in-law dynamics! I am also curious how Carly is showering if her clothes are in the bathtub! HOWWW.

    I definitely have lots of family drama of my own but I learned the hard way that you never know who is reading your blog. I once talked shit about a family member and it blew up in my face, so now I just try to leave family drama off my blog even there is so much I'd like to say/talk through!

    ReplyDelete
  10. I just.. whoa. OMG. Seriously? This is like a reality series, or a weird novel, at the least. I am totally with you - no grudges, please. They take way too much energy and time, and I would probably forget who I disliked and for what reason about, oh, 6 months in. I just can't be bothered! There are people in older generations in my mom's family (no longer with us) who held grudges until the day they died. My mom's perspective on it was the one I adopted - life is way too short for that kind of (crap).

    I am so glad you are literally and figuratively able to distance yourself from this! I do feel bad for Buddy, as well, and think he needs to just say "no more". But family dynamics can be sooooo hard. Sigh. Hang in there - I hope there are no further updates for a while but I imagine you'll share them when they happen. ;)

    ReplyDelete