Wednesday, March 29, 2023

5.29 Song - Feminist Country

Bestest Friend and I are doing a blog project. Each day we will write a blog post on a pre-determined theme chosen by a random noun generator. The theme for the twenty-ninth day of the month is "Song."

****************

I'm not saying anything new by mentioning this, but the role of women performers in country music in 2023 is pretty sad. If you turn on country radio, there are so many men singing, but it's quite rare to hear a female voice. Also, what the men are singing about is repetitive and sometimes a tiny bit offensive to my feminist heart. My husband has a '90s Country playlist that Apple Music has curated for him and I frequently call it the '90s Women Country playlist and the last time I called it that, he just sort of laughed. It's because there ARE women on it, as opposed to what's going on now.


I bring this up as I spent some time curating a Spotify playlist of feminist country songs and I started with these ladies and their hits from the '90s because I was a teenager during this time, so of course these are the songs that resonate with me the most.

Wynonna Judd - "I Saw the Light" (1992) - So take your cheating hands off my red dress/Cuz I ain't wearing this thing for you - Preach it, girl. Tell him how it is. 

Lorrie Morgan - "What Part of No" (1992) - Sir, if you don't mind I'd rather be alone/From the moment I walked in tonight/You've been coming on/If I've told you once I've told you twice/I'm just here to unwind - You tell him, Lorrie. The first time my husband heard this song, he was really shocked. This was played on the radio? Yep. Number one on the singles chart in February 1993. IMAGINE.

Mary Chapin Carpenter - "He Thinks He'll Keep Her" (1992) - When she was thirty-six she met him at their door/She said, "I'm sorry, I don't love you anymore" - Is this one of the best breakup songs ever written? You decide.

Pam Tillis - "Let That Pony Run" (1993) - She got a divorce and a chestnut horse/And a barn with an old hayloft - Maybe this is the best breakup song? (Have we talked about how we went to a Pam Tillis concert once and I started following her on Instagram and she liked a photo of Hannah once and I AM DEAD over here because Pam Tillis once spent .5 seconds thinking about my darling pooch?)

Tanya Tucker - "Tell Me About It" (1993) - Somebody lowered the boom on you/Now you need a sympathetic ear - I really didn't know just how good I had it in the '90s, did I? You all! This song is a banger! We all know that "Two Sparrows in a Hurricane" (1992) and "Delta Dawn" (1972) are Tucker's best songs, though, right?

Patty Loveless "Blame It On Your Heart" (1993) - Blame it on your lying, cheating, cold deadbeating, two-timing, double-dealing, mean mistreating loving heart - Honestly, this song is amazing.

Martina McBride - "Independence Day" (1994) - Talk about your revolution/It's Independence Day - I will maintain that McBride has one of the best voices in country music and her ability to write songs about domestic violence and the role patriarchy plays in the destruction of families and relationships is unbeatable. "A Broken Wing" (1997) delves into similar themes of abuse/child abuse and while I don't like that the answer is suicide in both cases, I do like that McBride really advocated for domestic violence victims in a time when it was difficult to do so. 

Trisha Yearwood - "XXX's and OOO's (An American Girl)" (1994) - Got a picture of her mama in heels and pearls/She's gonna make it in her daddy's world/She's an American girl - Trisha Yearwood is not always my jam, but I rock out to this one.

Terri Clark - "Better Things To Do" (1995) - I don't need to waste my time/Crying over you/I got better things to do - That's right, Terri. There are so many things you could be doing instead of fretting over that guy.

Shania Twain - "Any Man of Mine" (1995) - Any man of mine'll say it fits just right/When last year's dress is just a little too tight/And anything I do or say better be okay/When I have a bad hair day - I mean, who here disagrees with Shania?

Faith Hill - "I Can't Do That Anymore" (1996) - I used to dream about what I could be/Last night I dreamed about the washing machine - I really feel like this song is in conversation with "He Thinks He'll Keep Her."

LeAnn Rimes - "One Way Ticket" (1996) - I will face the world around me/Knowing that I'm strong enough to let you go/And I will fall in love again/Because I can - I am a Rimes fangirl, too, so it's no surprise that I struggled with which song to use here. Shoutouts to "Big Deal" (1999) and "Probably Wouldn't Be This Way" (2005), too.

Mindy McCready - "Guys Do It All The Time" (1996) - So I had some beers with the girls last night/Guys do it all the time - I mean, sure I prefer songs in which women are better than men, but I like how this song demonstrates a double-standard. 

The Chicks - "Wide Open Spaces" (1998) - She needs wide open spaces/Room to make her big mistakes/She needs new faces/She knows the higher stakes - I might argue that The Chicks did their best works in the 2000s with "Goodbye Earl" in 2000 and "Not Ready To Make Nice" in 2006, but I listened to the Wide Open Spaces album on repeat in my dorm room, so I am not here to say that the 1990s didn't provide me with great Chicks content.

Deana Carter - "Did I Shave My Legs For This?" (1997) - I bought these new heels, did my nails/Had my hair done just right/I thought this new dress was a sure bet/For romance tonight - Another album that made it into repeat in my dorm room. 

Jo Dee Messina - "He'd Never Seen Julie Cry" (1997) - Thought he'd outrun her like the others/Leave her somewhere down the line/But then again he'd never seen Julie cry - I am a HUGE Messina fan and between this song and her remake of Dottie West's "Lesson in Leavin'" (1999), I was immediately hooked on her as an artist. 

SHeDAISY - "Little Good-Byes" (1999) - Took your favorite Dodgers cap/Left the litter, but I took the cat - Ha ha ha!! I had forgotten how GOOD this song is. Snappy and earwormy and hilarious. 

You know what's number one on country music charts this week? Morgan Wallen, he of racial slurs and non-apologies. 

For fun, I added a handful of other songs to this list that aren't from the 1990s, mostly because I feel like Loretta Lynn should get some airtime.

Lesley Gore - "You Don't Own Me" (1963) - You don't own me/I'm not just one of your many toys/You don't own me/Don't say I can't go with other boys - How amazing is it that Gore was just seventeen when she performed this song? 

Dolly Parton - "Just Because I'm A Woman" (1968) - Yes, I've made mistakes/But listen and understand/My mistakes are no worse than yours/Just because I'm a woman - With this song, "9 to 5" (1980), and "Why'd You Come In Here Looking Like That?" (1989), Dolly has to be on this list. Fun fact: "9 to 5" was the first song the DJ played at our wedding reception. I did not request this, but I LOVED it.

Linda Ronstadt - "Different Drum" (1974) - I think this is when she was with the Stone Poneys? I can't tell. Anyway. I love the line "All I'm saying is that I'm not ready for any person, place, or thing to try to pull the reins in on me." Go, girl.

Loretta Lynn - "The Pill" (1975) - This incubator is overused because you've kept it filled/But feeling good comes easy now since I've got the pill - I LOVE that Lynn wrote a song about how sexual and reproductive freedom that came with the birth control pill. I also love SO MANY OF HER SONGS, including "Fist City" (1968), "Don't Come Home A-Drinkin' (With Lovin' On Your Mind)" (1966), and "Miss Being Mrs." (2004).  

Okay, I was going to keep going, but I ran out of time. There are fifty songs on the playlist and if you're the kind of person who is really upset that bro country continues to rule the airwaves, check it out. 

14 comments:

  1. Are Lesley Gore and Linda Ronstadt really considered country?

    I cannot abide country music of any kind, but I appreciate your advocacy of Feminism in any arena. Because of Big Sister Idolatry, I listened to a lot of Single Female Seventies Music, and now, when I listen to the lyrics, it's really bothersome to me. Even Aretha sings about wanting/needing her man to complete her. So irritating. (Of course, she did sing her Respect anthem, too.) That's why I get annoyed with Taylor Swift, who I think is a terrific talent. So much whining about a man.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hmmm...I guess I do think of Linda Ronstadt as sort of crossover country. Lesley Gore is maybe a stretch for this list, but I do think this song has a country flavor.

      Ha! I adore Taylor Swift, but I do agree that she has a lot of songs about heartbreak. I did add a TS song to the playlist, but it was surprisingly hard to find one that wasn't all "screw the haters" or "I'm so sad about my breakup." Do better, Taylor. Do better.

      Delete
  2. Oooooh- love this Not my fave genre, but I do really like some of these artists.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This was SUCH a fun read. Going through the list, each song playing in my brain. You are right: Two Sparrows in a Hurricane is AMAZING. And Independence Day is such a belter. I can't NOT sing along to that one. I admit to having a soft spot for Trisha Yearwood, and Xs and Os is one of my favorites. I also like Shania's "That Don't Impress Me Much."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Shania's entire catalog could really be included. "Man! I Feel Like a Woman!" is another great song that I might add to the list. I suspect you and I have similar tastes in music and I'm so excited to learn this!

      Delete
  4. 90s country is still my favorite, especially because of all the amazing women. Bro country of the past decade - not so much.

    ReplyDelete
  5. LOOOOOOOOOOOOVE 90s Country!!!! I really don't listen to much current country anymore, not sure why, so I cannot say I have noticed if there are less current female artists or not. But I love so many of those you mentioned. Brings back so many good memories of high school + summertime for me!! :) In addition to the amazing female artists of that time, I also can't get enough of that era of Garth Brooks, Tim McGraw, etc. too. It's all wonderful!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. These songs really are the pinnacle of music for me - I too love Garth Brooks and Tim McGraw, but I feel like the era of the popular "hat acts" are what eventually led to the state of country music today and I somehow feel like Alan Jackson and George Strait let us all down somehow.

      Delete
  6. I am NOT a country music fan...at all. Cue the boos. I have never even heard of Pam Tillis, but can assume she has excellent taste based on her love of Hannah!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I LOVE Pam Tillis. I must listen to "Let That Pony Run" at least twice a week. It never gets old.

      Delete
  7. I never listen to country music, so I hardly knew any of the songs on your list. I am, however, surprised and intrigued that country music nowadays is dominated by men. Why would that be? When I think of country, I think of female singers. What is going on here? I'm glad you're promoting strong female artists, even if it is from 20 years ago.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jody Rosen coined the term bro county in an article in 2013. It's a combination of things, really, that led to this state of affairs. Lack of female program directors at radio stations, a move towards implementing more hip-hop/popular music trends in country music (trends that also exclude women in those formats), and a focus on the male gaze more generally in popular culture.

      Just as an example of how this plays out, let's talk about Tomato-Gate. In 2015, a male radio consultant named Keith Hill said that women musicians were the "tomatoes" to the male-artist "salad" and his advice to get good ratings in country music was to "take females out." (I'm not even going to get started on using the terms "females" to describe women.) Many women artists took umbrage with this, as you can imagine, and there were lots of "let the tomatoes play" tshirts and Margo Price had a brilliant quote about "You say tomato, I say fuck you."

      But, it has had a lasting influence, since the percentage of women who are played on charts, writing songs, and winning awards consistently keep sliding downward. It's CMT so Bro.
      https://www.tennessean.com/story/entertainment/music/2015/06/18/tomato-gate-galvanizes-women-country/28936501/
      https://www.npr.org/2019/04/05/710262673/country-music-excludes-women-especially-over-age-40-study-finds

      Delete
  8. I don’t follow these things, so I am unaware of trends. I do know that Blake is leaving The Voice, and that is just about it. 🤓

    ReplyDelete
  9. YOU ARE MY PEOPLE. OMG, I love this so much. I'm right. there. with. you. I hate what country is now, and refuse to listen or even read about the country bros. The Chicks were the soundtrack to my early-2000s life (starting out in my career)... they accompanied me through many (many) changes. I love them even now (have you listened to their new, not-really-country album from a few years ago?).
    I know Brandi Carlile isn't country, but I have a Chicks-and-Brandi playlist on YouTube that I really need to transition to Apple music or Spotify. I think of it as my badass women soundtrack. I haven't listened to it recently, and...you're making me realize I need to. ;)
    Saved your playlist. It's amazing.

    ReplyDelete