Everything Is Tuberculosis by John Green is the current It Book of the Interwebz.
He met a young boy with TB and it sent him off on years of research about the disease. If you had asked me before I read this book, I would have said that I thought TB was a disease of the past, a disease of Romantic poets and the Brontës. But, as we find out in the first five pages of this book, that could not be further from the truth.
Still, over a million people died of tuberculosis in 2023. That year, in fact, more people died of TB than died of malaria, typhoid, and war combined. (page 4)
Today, we understand tuberculosis as an infection caused by bacteria. TB is airborne - it spreads from person to person through small particles contained in coughs, sneezes, or exhalations. Anyone can get tuberculosis - in fact, between one-quarter and one-third of all living humans have been infected with it. In most people, the infection will lie dormant for a lifetime. But up to 10 percent of the infected will eventually become sick, a phenomenon we call "active TB." (page 5-6)
There is a cure for TB - antibiotics - but, as you can imagine, the distribution of antibiotics across the globe is unequal and countries that are poorer and/or have poor infrastructure for transporting medicines have citizens who suffer rates of TB at higher rates than more well-developed nations. This books tells the story of how this came to be.
And it's super interesting. It's really important - I think drawing attention to the fact that literal millions of people are dying because of TB is an interesting thing for Green to do with his platform. I hope it brings more money to getting medicines to the populations in most need.
But I find John Green's writing tic of inserting himself into every story to be...annoying? distracting? self-absorbed? Why do I have to know he has OCD? Why do I have to know about his brother's cancer? It's not relevant, but Green obviously can't resist but making every story about himself. He doesn't have TB and if he had, it would have been treated quickly in the US with the proper medication. This has a 4.55/5 stars on Goodreads, so I'm obviously in the minority her because I wish this book had been written by a different author.
3/5 stars
Lines of note:
The United States of America, Charles Dickens once noted, was "a nation of spitters." People spit on trolleys and on sidewalks, on restaurant floors and even in the home. (page 98)
"Yes," I said.
"None. Zero. Zero people should die of TB."
It is difficult to imagine eliminating tuberculosis entirely. The disease has many animal reservoirs, and because a quarter of all people living are infected with it, the total elimination of TB is a distant dream. But we could live in a world where no one dies of TB. (page 181)
Things I looked up:
multidimensionally poor (page 25) - A person who is poor can suffer multiple disadvantages at the same time – for example they may have poor health or malnutrition, a lack of clean water or electricity, poor quality of work or little schooling. Focusing on one factor alone, such as income, is not enough to capture the true reality of poverty.
Hat mentions (why hats?):
"Did you know tuberculosis helped give us the cowboy hat?" (page 14)
Regaining his health over the next few years, John noticed something different about the West: The hats sucked. Fur traders of European descent often wore bug-infested, brimless coonskin caps. Folks who made their way to Missouri from Texas and Mexico, meanwhile, tended to wear wide-brimmed straw hats that protected from the sun but leaked in the rain. So after returning to the northeast with his consumption under control, John B. Stetson created a new sort of hat, which in time came to be known as the cowboy hat. (page 16)
I've read a few John Green books and I've enjoyed them - both fiction - I might pick this one up! *checks library stack* MAYBE LATER, OMG. I'm behind on my stacks! There was a TB outbreak in Kelowna's hospital right after we moved here. I haven't heard anything about it so it must be fine now.
ReplyDeleteI realized I only had four library books and went on a spree and now I have eight more coming in. I am so excited about my bounty of books!!
DeleteCan you imagine a TB outbreak? I honestly cannot. I truly thought it was not a thing anymore, so this book was quite eye-opening for me.
This actually sounds pretty good! I don't know if all the personal notes about the author would bother me. I like the tidbit about TB and the cowboy hat.
ReplyDeleteHe does write some fun anecdotes about how TB has influenced history. I think you'll like it if you like that sort of historical writing.
Delete"I wish this book had been written by a different author" cracked me up, Engie. I saw this book at the bookstore recently -- after having heard / read somewhere about TB being a scourge of the current era -- and am grateful to you for having read it and shared the relevant portions.
ReplyDeleteWas that mean? I tried so hard not to be mean. It's just that he has this big stage and he's a super popular author and all he can do is talk about his own health conditions? I don't know. I'm glad I read it, though, because I learned a lot.
DeleteI'd read this! JG's tangents are interesting, so I'm willing to go along. It's the boring and the mundane that I simply cannot suffer.
ReplyDeleteUgh. I despise author inserts. That's a me problem, I guess.
DeleteThis is the kind of stuff that I like to read. I'm ready to go back to nonfiction in a big way, having been largely disappointed by contemporary fiction overall. I need some deep nerdy stuff that I won't constantly edit and rewrite in my head as I read.
ReplyDeleteYou know, I don't mind the occasional aside and personalization of a narrative. I like when the author can relate to the subject matter. As an English teacher, one of the things I was trained to look for in my students was whether or not they could personally relate to the literature. It was an important objective that showed higher-order thinking and emotional connection. It was something I strove for. If the author is doing it, maybe that's why and a good thing.
I thought his original story about going to a tuberculosis hospital in Sierra Leone was super interesting (and relevant). But the rest of it just took me out of the information and made it the John Green show. *shrug* Maybe it's a me problem. I do not care for author inserts in writing. It's one of the reasons I rarely read memoir or autobiography.
DeleteI plan to read this on my kindle but the wait is pretty long. My aunt and uncle both had TB in the last 10 years. My uncle was having all these issues with his ears and saw doctor after doctor and eventually ended up at Mayo where they figured out he had TB. And then his wife had it, too. If I remember correctly, the course of antibiotics is rather aggressive? I remember that my aunt and uncle were very ashamed to have it and didn't want anyone to know which is kind of odd. I mean, who can control getting something like that? I have been tested for TB because of the strong immune-suppressant medications I take. Before I could start Enbrel, they had to test me for TB. It was an odd test where they put something in my wrist and if a bubble formed, it meant I had TB or something like that.
ReplyDeleteGreat comment! Green does talk about the stigma of TB. Because it's so contagious (and because it's mostly identified with black and brown people in the contemporary world), it has a huge stigma in many parts of the world. The regimen for antibiotics IS intense and there are a lot of antibiotic resistant forms that require even more. Compliance with taking medication is frequently low for that reason. It's really tough for people who are multidimensionally poor (the term I looked up) because they might not have access to food and water, let alone the ability to go to a clinic every day to take antibiotics.
DeleteWell now I don’t have to read the book, because you gave me the info I needed.
ReplyDelete1. That it is in so many of us and lays dormant, which is super interesting to me because it explains why when one wants to work (or volunteer) at a school (at least in California) one has to take a TB test first. I thought to myself, “wouldn’t I know?” And clearly, the answer is no.
2. That it is entirely treatable. That is tragic, given how many people die from it still, but also reassuring at a personal level.
I recently listened to a book of his, The Anthropocene Reviewed, and I really liked the essays I read, but then I gave up on it about 2/3 through, and I’m not sure why. I think I was tired of hearing about how his condition affected pretty much everything. Which I guess is fair, because when one has OCD or a family member with cancer, it does bleed into every aspect of your life. But also, got a little old.
It was super interesting and I'm glad I read it. I have found a lot of books about specific diseases interesting (The Kissing Bug is about Chagas) and I would put this one in that category. But I really do think that John Green is just not the right author for me.
DeleteI've only read one book by this author and it was okayish – if it is the same author.
ReplyDeleteI actually had a case I the family just over Christmas where my cousins little girl was diagnosed with TB. Crazy stuff. You would believe it is an old time denies but no it is not. How ydo you even catch it...
It's super contagious. TB germs can get into the air when someone with active TB disease coughs, speaks, or sings. People nearby may breathe in these germs and become infected. (People with inactive TB cannot spread it.) There are also a lot of animals with TB and bovine tuberculosis can be spread through the ingestion of contaminated material (think: milk). Animal-to-animal transmission does not have to just be human-to-human. It's interesting and scary!
DeleteIf I recall correctly, wasn't there a recent outbreak somewhere in the Midwest? I remember asking my doctor about it.
ReplyDeleteLooks like there's currently an outbreak in Kansas City, Kansas. Not great, but at least in the US everyone will presumably get treatment. (Although I guess there's no guarantee with health insurance the way it is.)
DeleteI've learned so much about tuberculosis from this post. Wow. I've not read anything by this author, but I agree - why does he need to insert himself into the story? I'm envisioning Forest Gump's video cameos at the White House in the movie.
ReplyDeleteYeah, I think it's good to know the basics of TB even if you don't read this book.
DeleteI've heard of this book and honestly, I didn't think that it dealt with TB directly, more like it was a metaphor for something. Hmmmm....sounds like it could be a good one, aside from the Authors insertion.
ReplyDeleteIt was really interesting and I do feel like I learned a lot reading it.
DeleteCoincentally (I love book synergy even if it's meaningless) my friend Nat was just talking about reading this book. I didn't realize until just now that it was by John Green. I knew TB was still bad even in the states because i watch way too many medical dramas (but I learned something, ha ha)
ReplyDeleteI mean, it shouldn't be bad in the States because we have access to treatment! I say this as a measles outbreak is currently happening, so....
Delete