Tuesday, January 21, 2025

Real Americans by Rachel Khong

 I read Real Americans by Rachel Khong because Lisa recommended it. 


What we have here is a multi-generational immigrant story. We start with Lily Chen who is interning in New York City at the turn of the century. She falls in love with a white man and they start a family together. Then in the second part of the novel, we speed ahead in time to pandemic era Seattle where we learn about Lily's son Nick. In the third part of the novel, we're traveling ahead in time to catch up with Lily's mother, Nick's grandmother, a woman originally from China who became as successful scientist in the United States, but maybe wasn't as successful in her personal life. 

I found this a difficult book to get into. Lily was sort of a non-character at first. But then, suddenly, I wanted to learn more. I wanted to learn about Lily's past and what she hoped for herself in the future. I wanted to know what her parenting philosophy would be and how it would be different from her own parents. I wanted to know things about Lily. And we sort of go there, but then it switched to talk about Nick, who was an interesting character in his own right, but I wanted Lily's story.

And that's what it comes down to for me. This was a good book, but it wasn't a great book. I wanted it to go deeper into Lily. I wanted her to talk about race and what it was like to be married to a white man and have a child who didn't look anything like her. I wanted to know her feelings about her estranged mother and ex-husband. I wanted to know if she ever thought about her relationship with her mother and what it demonstrated for own son. I wanted to know more about Lily. Why didn't she ask her own parents more questions? What were her ambitions in life? And that's all before we get to Lily's mother's story. 

I think this is the reason I prefer plot-driven stories, to be honest. This was a character-driven story and it was GOOD. But it would have to be five times as long as it was if it were to answer all the questions I still had about the characters after I closed the book cover. 

4/5 stars

Line of note:
There were things about Timothy I wished would rub off on my - most of all his ease in who he was. He never seemed to experience the uncertainty I felt. It was as though he'd emerged from the womb perfectly secure in who he would be and what he was capable of, like a giraffe that could stan an hour after being born. (page 171)

Hat mentions (why hats?): 
...I dodged tourists wearing backpacks and bucket hats, holding red bags from the discount designer store. (page 8)
As I walked to the stage to collect my diploma, my hat slid further down, looking silly, like I was poking fun at the ritual. (page 39)
She wore a sun hat with an enormous brim. (page 85)
...who tipped an imaginary hat. (page 169)
She stood in the doorway of my dorm, wearing a knitted hat and scarf of matching, multicolored yarn. (page 211)
...a shopping bag revealed to contain a hat, gloves, and a down comforter. (page 211)

17 comments:

  1. I really liked the first part of the book, and then I liked it less as it went on. That said, we are opposites as I love having unanswered questions that I can think about, not that I have been thinking about this book since I read it or anything, but it's something I really enjoy about books like this. I thought it was a remarkable piece of literature, the writing was great. But as I said I liked it less as the book went on - I think I also gave it four stars.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, I think the first part is the strongest. We definitely agree on that. I almost wish it had been a trilogy with each book focusing on the different characters. But that would be a heck of a commitment on the part of readers.

      Delete
  2. If I'm reading a book, I want a story. To me, "character driven" means nothing happens. I would also want all the details of Lily's story.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I recently wrote "nothing happened in this book" on a DNF. LOL. I just want plot!

      Delete
  3. I never thought it mattered whether or not a book was character driven vs plot, but then I finally read a book (the name is escaping me, ugh) that so many people loved and it was fine- but I was like nothing happened.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. YES!! That book is The Berry Pickers. Like...the first chapter was exciting and then it was just people moping around. (I don't know really know if you read TBP, but it is an accurate description of the book.)

      Delete
  4. This is probably a book that I should go back and re-rate. I liked it more when I finished, but it became a bit more forgettable as time passed. I think I initially rated it 5 stars, but it's probably more like a 4 star read for me. I agree that Lily's story was the best part of the book, though.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, you were so hot on it! And then it didn't make your top books of the year list. LOL. Oh, well. It wasn't bad - it just wasn't what I wanted.

      Delete
  5. On the subject of character-driven books, I once read a book where things did happy, but every character's motivation was described in excruciating detail, which was fine for me but when someone on Goodreads described it as "more plot-driven than other books" I would have spit out my tea if I was drinking tea.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is crazy how different readers interpret different books. What's plot to one person is character to another, I guess.

      Delete
  6. I am like Jenny; I need something to happen, so I will probably skip this book! I don't mind some character driven novels, but some just seem like pages and pages of nothing and that starts to annoy me!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree. I need plot. I will settle in for character driven occasionally, but generally I need something to happen.

      Delete
  7. Have you read "A Great Country" (Shilpi Somaya Gowda) by chance? Another multi-generational immigrant story in which the title ends up being sarcastic. I really enjoyed this one.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have not read it! I'll add it to my list and see when it fits in.

      Delete
  8. I have never thought about if I prefer plot driven or character driven stories. I am not sure I could actually differentiate the two.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh, I bet you could. If you read a book and someone asks you to summarize it, do you immediately start talking about plot or about the characters? That's how you can tell!

      Delete
    2. Oh that is such a good approach to figuring it out. I think I will pay attention to i when i talk about books to my husband. I have a feeling its plot driven but I will observe.

      Delete