Okay, I always say I don't judge a book by its cover, but it has become abundantly clear to me that this is a lie. I will comment on a great cover (and here and here) and bad ones. I will puzzle over cartoony covers with matter that is anything but cartoony. I will be irate if the cover spoils the book. Part of it is that I try not to know very much about a book going into it and sometimes the only thing I know is what is on the cover.
So if you saw the cover for Julie Chan is Dead by Liann Zhang and all you know about it is that it has something to do with influencer culture, what would you think this was about? And, further, what genre would you say it was about?
Well, this book is a thriller? Horror? I don't know.
Julie Chan and her sister Chloe were separated when they were small children when their parents died. Julie was raised by a neglectful aunt and Chloe was raised by a wealthy white couple. Julie is now struggling to make ends meet as a cashier and Chloe is an influencer and they're mostly estranged. One day Julie gets a mysterious call from her sister and when she goes to check on Chloe, Chloe is dead. So, as you do, Julie TAKES OVER CHLOE'S IDENTITY AND LIFE.
Look, don't go digging into whether or not this is a realistic situation. It is not. But I put on my suspension of disbelief persona and kept reading. (No, I did not. I talked nonstop to my husband about how stupid this was.)
Okay, well, Chloe was part of a pack of influencer people and they all go on an island vacation together with Julie pretending to be Chloe and SHIT GETS WEIRD. I'm not going to say what happens on this island, but I didn't expect these events based on the cover or the rest of the book. It's like the book took a TURN at 70%. You've been warned.
Once again, I can't figure out how to link to direct Goodreads reviews, but Yun wrote this:
and basically Yun is right. I'm old, I don't understand influencer culture, and the satire is lost on me. What is Zhang trying to say here? That influencers are bad for society? Echoes of what true beliefs are? Evil? Is she trying to say something about class divisions? That even wealthy people can be as unhappy as the rest of us plebes? That there's nothing authentic in the world anymore, particularly online? I DON'T KNOW. The messages were too mixed and I'm too old to understand anything about the chronically online. (Unless we're talking about chronically online bloggers, which...huh. Anyone here want to go on an island vacation with me where WEIRD SHIT will happen?)
I think if I had cared more about any of these characters, maybe it wouldn't matter that I don't truly understand the real message. But since each of the influencer characters, including Julie and Chloe, are written as villainous, I just couldn't really feel anything about this book except revulsion and a tiny bit of joy at the unexpected batshit nature of it all.
Eh.
Maybe I'm just not the right generation or right audience.
2.5/5 stars
Lines of note:
...was working my usual morning shift, ringing up bananas (4011) and a bag of chia seeds for a platinum-haired lady with a shrieking baby clawing at her breast. (location 68)
Have you ever worked as a grocery store cashier? When I worked at Meijer, a large regional supercenter in the Midwest, the lady who trained me told me that the code for bananas was the first code you learned and the last one you forgot. And she was right. I don't know any of the other produce codes, but bananas are 4011.
An old woman wearing a thick brown trench coat walks her Pomeranian across the street. The dog has little neon-green boots. (location 1656)
Aw. Little booted puppy.
And it’s not like I’m the worst. Out of the major influencers, I’m at the bottom of the food chain. Imagine what the people in the double or triple millions are doing. At least I’m not running crypto-scams or filming dead bodies in suicide forests or dancing for TikTok in front of Auschwitz. (location 2013)
The bar is so low, isn't it?
Things I looked up:
gacha machine (location 2014) - (or gashapon machine) is a Japanese capsule toy vending machine. Users insert coins or tokens, turn a mechanical crank, and receive a random toy packed inside a plastic capsule. - Look. We just called these gumball machines.
new chara on Genshin (location 2064) - Genshin Impact is an open-world adventure RPG. New characters on Genshin. Boy, do I feel dumb for having to think this through a lot.
Title spotting:
Julie Chan is dead. Julie Chan is dead. Julie Chan is dead. See? Nothing. In a way, Julie Chan is dead. (location 959)
Hat mentions (why hats?):
blankets and wool hats (location 1755)
Shirts, dresses, jeans, sunglasses, hats. (location 2012)
beach chair, sun hat, and flip-flops (location 2015)
Someone sends a cowboy hat. (location 3551)
wearing the hat (location 3551)
Tinfoil hats aren’t part of my brand, but they’ve become my loudest supporters regardless. (location 4267)
*****************
Do you want to read a book about influencer culture? Do you wish you'd never heard the world influencer?







.png)










