One of the prompts for the Pop Sugar Reading Challenge this year is to read a book about a running club. There is no way I'm going to finish that challenge this year, but I'm still plodding around, thinking maybe I can do most of it. I decided I'd read Haruki Murakami's memoir What I Talk About When I Talk About Running for this, although if I'm being 100% accurate, it's not really about a running club. Close enough for me.
I know that this is a beloved memoir and everything I am about to say is going to be blasphemy to a lot of you.
I didn't like this.
It talks a lot about body image and body shaming. It talks a lot about running.
What, you ask me, did you expect?
I guess I expected this to be about writing with a little bit about running. Instead it was about running with a little bit about writing. If that's your jam, go ahead and read it. It was not my jam, although I listened to the audiobook and the narrator made it all go down easy.
3/5 stars
Lines of note:
In every interview I'm asked what's the most important quality a novelist has to have? It's pretty obvious - talent. No matter how much enthusiasm and effort you put into writing, if you totally lack literary talent, you can forget about being a novelist. This is more of a prerequisite than a necessary quality. If you don't have any fuel, even the best car won't run. (timestamp 1:53:18)
What a pep talk. *eyeroll*
Most of what I know about writing I've learned through running every day. These are practical, physical lessons. How much can I push myself? How much rest is appropriate and how much is too much? How far can I take something and still keep it decent and consistent? When does it become narrowminded and inflexible? How much should I be aware of the world outside and how much should I focus on my inner world? To what extent should I be confident in my abilities and when should I start doubting myself? (timestamp 2:01:49)
This was an interesting passage and I wish he'd talked a lot more about these parallels. Unfortunately, this was the meat of it.
Once when I had a chance to talk with a sales rep from Mizuno he admitted, "our shoes are kind of plain and don't stand out. We stand by our quality but they aren't that attractive." I know what he's trying to say - they have no gimmicks, no sense of style, no catchy slogan, so to the average consumer they have little appeal - the Subaru of the shoe world, in other words. (timestamp 2:16:51)
I have to admit having laughed pretty hard at this. One of the cars that is on our list of potential cars is a Subaru. No one over here is IN LOVE with it, though. It's fine.
Still the most significant fallout from running the ultramarathon wasn't physical, but mental. What I ended up with was a sense of lethargy and before I knew it, I felt covered by a thin film, something I've since dubbed runner's blues, although the actual feeling of it was closer to a milky white. (timestamp 2:53:18)
WTF does this mean? Milky white?
Hat mentions (why hats?):
..take off my hat, which I had on to keep the sun off me. I'd worn the hat to keep my head warm... (timestamp 2:38:41)
***************
Anyone else read this? Think less of Murakami now that they've read it? I've obliquely mentioned our car search a couple of times in this space - would anyone be interested in a full-length post on our endless search?

Yes! Car search is interesting to me, we spent a long time searching too - we have different requirements than most people: low to the ground so Edda can get in, big trunk to fit a wheelchair and electric and not Tesla. Took a long time - we got a Kia E6. This is the only Murakami I've read because I'm a runner - I've tried the other ones, but I haven't been able to get into them. I thought this running Murakami was...ok, not great. Apparently I'm difficult to satisfy bookwise.
ReplyDeleteIt turns out that every car we test drive is fine. And that's fine. But I want one to wow me.
DeleteMaybe Murakami just isn't the right author for you and that's fine! There are lots of other good authors out there.
Hmm! I've seen this book around but never read it. After reading your review I'll skip it- there are too many great books out there, this one sounds kind of "meh."
ReplyDeleteTalent is overrated. "Hard work beats talent that doesn't work hard" is one of our family mottos. Well- my husband and I say it, the kids are tired of hearing it.
I mean, I do agree that talent matters. But hard work is overrated, imo. LOL. I don't think I'd be a good parent.
DeleteThat sounds like an interesting book if one were into running, but I’m not. I liked the paragraph about the parallels between running and writing, though, so thank you for sharing that.
ReplyDeleteSubarus are great cars, though we are mostly a Toyota family here. My Pacific Northwest family all drive Subarus, though, and love them.
Subarus are hit or miss cars, to be honest. When you get one that doesn't work, repair is a nightmare. And they are boring to drive. But in my post about this never-ending search, I'll touch on why it's even on our list.
DeleteI run, but only because it's a faster way to complete my workout vs walking and I have things to do. So, a book about running, that wouldn't interest me. I'm with you on the confusion over the milky white. What does that even mean? The Subaru thing was funny. If I didn't have a kid who sold cars, my search would be a lot harder I imagine. He has a new job now, but I'll still have him weigh in when I want to shop for a car. He knows stuff.
ReplyDeleteI would LOVE to be able to run. It's such an efficient cardio workout. Alas, it makes me leg hurt for days, so I'm stuck with low-impact cardio. Sad news for me. I'll never have a build like Murakami as he will endlessly point out in this book.
DeleteI haven't read this but honestly (again, probably blasphemy) I don't love Murakami's writing in general. Books about a sport are difficult, whether fiction or non-fiction. It's definitely possibly to write about running and other sports in an engaging way even for non-athletes, but I think it's hard to sustain for a whole book.
ReplyDeleteYes to all your points! I liked 1Q84 and think about it all the time, but it's definitely not a book for everyone. And books about sports are hard for non-athletes because I find the single-mindedness to be so frustrating. Life is about more than just sport!!
Delete